Silverwood is a multi-generational gathering of folks from all walks of life.  Some have grown up in the church and have been living the Jesus way for many years, and others are still checking this whole thing out.  Wherever you’ve been, no matter who you are, or what you do, our hope is that you will know you are welcome here.


Statement of Invitation

As Silverwood Mennonite Church we proclaim Jesus as Lord and affirm the authority of the Bible. We acknowledge a diversity of perspectives, practices, and biblical understandings. We commit to living in community, to practicing peacemaking that transcends all barriers, and to welcoming all.


We recognize the sacred worth and dignity of all people and celebrate that persons of every age, ethnicity, race, gender identity, sexual orientation, marital status, education, intellectual or emotional or physical ability, and economic or immigration status are created in the image of God. As a diverse faith community we recognize that we don’t all agree, but in love we extend grace to each other.  We invite all people who proclaim Jesus as Lord, including LGBTQ+ persons, to fully participate in the life of our congregation, including membership, baptism, marriage, leadership, and pastoral ministry. 


Come join our community as we strive to follow Jesus together.

What are Sunday’s like?

A message, singing, time of prayer… the usual.  However, we believe in using everyone’s gifts rather than just a select few professionals, so you will see a variety of people involved in the services, each bringing their unique flavor and heart to our corporate gatherings.  The music is a blend of more traditional and modern worship songs.


Some folks dress very casual for Sunday services and others prefer suit and tie.  Be you.  Wear what you’d like to wear. A typical service lasts about 80 minutes.

What about kids?

Kids over age 4 join their parents and caregivers for the main worship service.  We often have a children’s story that relates to the topic or scripture of the day. Child care in a safe and clean environment next to the sanctuary is provided for children under 4 during the worship service.


Are Sunday services the main thing going on?

Absolutely not!  We have a growing network of Dinner Groups that meet throughout the Goshen area.  These are smaller gatherings meant to foster relationships and support one another in our faith journey.  To us, this is also where church happens.  As we eat together, share life’s ups and downs with each other, pray for one another and learn Jesus together, we experience what it means to be connected to others also on the journey.


Founded in 1892 with 50 charter members,Silver Street Mennonite Church grew rapidly to 200 members by the turn of the century. By 1913 Silver Street had planted two churches: Topeka Mennonite and Eighth Street Mennonite. The congregation was known for supporting Mennonite mission work overseas and has been a home base for many missionaries, maintaining connections to the church in the Congo to this day.


As a little rural church with declining attendance in the 1980’s, the members knew that some tough decisions would need to be made going forward.  With a renewed vision for growth and to create belonging and family for more people, Silver Street changed its name, bought land on the west side of Goshen, and built a new building to be closer to where people lived, worked and interacted.


As Silverwood Mennonite Church, the congregation again experienced rapid growth, attracting many young adults from the local college community.


Today, Silverwood’s members are very active in the community, seeking creative ways to bless others and share the love of Jesus in practical, hands on ways.  Conversations about church planting are once again on the table, as we desire to share the Good News that we’ve experienced with even more people.  


Silverwood is a member congregation of Central District Conference and Mennonite Church USA.



Jeremy Shue

Jeremy serves as Pastoral Team Leader.  He also works bi-vocationally at an industrial recycling start-up. Jeremy has a passion for people connecting their faith with their everyday lives - whether that is in a factory, office, school, hospital, home or wherever they find themselves during the week.


As Pastoral Team Leader, Jeremy challenges the congregation to live into the vision that God has given Silverwood through preaching, teaching, and reaching out to the surrounding community.  


Jeremy enjoys spending time with his wife, Laura, and their four children. Most days he dreams of riding mountain bike in the RedBull Rampage and practices on the local trails at least 5 times a year. He loves travelling and enjoys experiencing other cultures through food and conversation. Really he’s up for anything as long as it is with fun people.  

Donna Mast

Donna is Pastor of Worship and Pastoral Care. Trained as a spiritual director, Donna is passionate about helping people grow more deeply in their relationship with God and has many years of pastoral experience.

In her two roles, Donna divides her time between tending worship and tending people. She works with the pastoral team and worship commission to ensure that day-to-day details of planning and leading worship are covered. Together with the pastoral team and worship commission, she also looks at the long-term plans for worship, helping to set themes for worship. In her pastoral care role, Donna oversees pastoral and crisis care for those connected to the congregation, as well as empowering others to provide care.

Donna is married to Conrad. Conrad is also a pastor, presently serving in a transitional role.  Because they serve different congregations, the two particular enjoy the times they are able to worship together.  They have three adult children, Katie, Anna, and Rachel, as well as two grandsons, Theo and Obie. Conrad and Donna enjoy being with their grandsons, as well as exploring new places and making music together. Donna enjoys walking, reading, knitting and sewing, and delights in serving meals to company.

Jon & Aimee Weishaupt

Jon and Aimee are the Pastors of Youth and Discipling. Jon works bi-vocationally with the Goshen Fire Department. Jon has a passion for helping youth see their potential and walk with them in their journey. Aimee is passionate about helping people young and old to find new ways to connect with God and to know how deeply they are loved by God. 

As Pastor of Youth, Jon creates safe spaces for community, learning, and service among the youth. As Pastor of Discipling, Aimee provides and develops places of learning and growing for the youngest of our community to the oldest.  

Jon and Aimee have three children Rylee, Isaiah, and Isabelle. They live on a hobby farm that brings their family much joy and times of connection. They also enjoy playing games with friends, hosting meals at their home, being in nature, and relaxing together for a good movie and popcorn. 

Caitlin Lanctot (“Lahn-toe”), Administrative Assistant, grew up in Goshen, IN and graduated from Goshen College with a degree in Art Education. After teaching for 6 years, she has been primarily a stay-at-home mother. In addition to being a mom, Caitlin is a jewelry maker that creates metalwork and enamel jewelry. Her work is for sale locally and online in her Etsy shop, SheDreamsInColors. Caitlin is married to Andrew, and they have three children: Lily, age 10; Jack, age 8; and Henry, age 5. She enjoys making art of many kinds, thrifting, yardwork, time in the woods, and spending time with close friends. She loves color, good design, and people who make her laugh.  Caitlin's family calls Berkey Avenue Mennonite Fellowship their church home. She will be forever on a quest to find the perfect (gluten-free, dairy-free) chocolate chip cookie.

Janice Troyer

Janice serves as Pastor of Community Life with an emphasis on Young Adults. She focuses her time on life within the congregation, forming and equipping Dinner Groups and engaging with those ages 18-35. She has a passion for building community, authenticity and being real about living life together the Jesus way. She believes God created us to be in community and delights in creating space for people to grow together. Life is messy and beautiful and we need each other as we navigate it all.


Janice is married to Dallan and has three small children: Silas, Amelia and Judah. She loves hosting people in her home, all things fall, and creating delicious gluten free desserts. Games are an essential part of her life as well as friends, books, and outdoors.

Caitlin Lanctot


At Silverwood Mennonite Church we are committed to being and making disciples of Jesus.  You, God, call us to a deeper relationship with You, Your community, and to welcome others into Your Kingdom. We want to follow. We need You to… 


Show Us the WAY

Willfully Seek


Our lives are permeated by willfully seeking You, both corporately and individually, in the church building and at our homes, schools, offices, and factories.  


  • We dream of various expressions of worship that engage all kinds of people.  Some expressions are large and take place at the church building. Others take place in a small group in a home or other public location. All of these challenge people to grow as disciples of Jesus.  

  • We dream of offering resources to encourage and enhance our times of personally seeking the Spirit of 

  • God through prayer, meditation, and the study of scripture.

  • We dream of developing and equipping leaders of all ages to walk with us on our faith journey.


Active Community 


You call us to share our whole lives together as followers of Christ.  


  • We dream of every person having a place where they belong, a group that deeply knows them and cares for them, a place where they can sincerely ask any and all questions and not expect predetermined answers, a place where they can learn to follow Christ alongside of others.

  • We dream of every person participating in a group that either focuses on developing themselves as disciples of Christ or that intentionally focuses on reaching and teaching others to be disciples.

  • We dream of a community where everyone can recognize their giftedness, name their brokenness, and minister to others out of both. 


Yearning for God’s Kingdom 

Your Kingdom is breaking into this world, and You call us to actively invite others to experience it, right here, right now. 


  • We dream of planting and nurturing missional communities, far and near, large and small, and of welcoming more than 1000 people into these gatherings.

  • We dream of everyone at Silverwood putting their discipleship into practice by continuously working for justice in their workplaces and communities and inviting others to experience the good news of God’s Kingdom now.

  • We dream of providing multiple opportunities to serve in multiple formats, locally, domestically, and internationally so that everyone is presented with formal opportunities to use their gifts of ministry.

Mission and Vision


We'd love to hear from you

1745 W Lincoln Ave, Goshen, IN 46526